Why drug studies can’t be trusted
Big Pharma sure knows how to get the biggest bang for its big bucks–a new study finds a remarkable success rate for drugs in industry-funded studies.
In fact, they almost never fail.
The government-funded review of 546 drug trials published between 2000 and 2006 found that studies funded by the industry had positive outcomes 85 percent of the time.
Remember that number–it’s going to come up again.
Government-funded trials, on the other hand, were like a coin toss: They had positive outcomes 50 percent of the time.
Studies funded by nonprofits and other organizations were positive 72 percent of the time. I’m guessing that’s because of Big Pharma’s substantial influence among these groups. After all, the researchers also found that when these organizations received industry money, their studies also came up positive… (drumroll please)… 85 percent of the time.
A remarkable coincidence, wouldn’t you say? If we could have that kind of luck at the racetrack, we wouldn’t need retirement funds.
Studies done by nonprofits that did not receive Big Pharma money, on the other hand, were positive just 61 percent of the time.
And by “positive” I mean they were positive for the drug, of course–because there’s certainly nothing positive about them for you. The researchers looked at trials for meds like antidepressants, antipsychotics and proton-pump inhibitors–some of our most overused, unnecessary and ineffective drugs.
What’s more, the study also found that Big Pharma-funded trials didn’t always get published. In fact, the researchers say that just 32 percent of industry-funded trials are published within two years of the study’s completion, according to the analysis published in the Annals of Internal Medicine.
That means 68 percent are being swept under the carpet. You don’t have to wonder what they found–because other researchers have reported that studies that come up negative often don’t get published.
That would explain that 85 percent success rate.
And that’s not the only way they game the system. I’ve told you before about some of the ways Big Pharma works to make sure its studies come up roses.
One of their favorite tricks is shortening the study… cutting it right off once they get the result they’re looking for. One analysis earlier this year found that shortened studies often dramatically overstate drug effectiveness. (Read “Shortened studies favor Big Pharma.”)
Another analysis found that studies often reach conclusions that are completely at odds with the actual data. (Read “The scientific spin cycle.”)
So while the latest analysis isn’t exactly new, it’s more proof that you simply can’t trust anything that comes from the drug companies.
Not that you actually need more proof at this point.
Posted in House Calls.


